Lighting Up

Rabbi Yaakov Bieler

While the overwhelming majority of Halachic discussion concerning the festival of Chanuka focuses upon the lighting of the Menora [e.g., Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chayim, 671-81], primary sources also mention other aspects of the holiday, at least in passing. [Even Chanuka parties, albeit not specifically mandated by the Halachic tradition, are posited as optional positive features of the festival by RaMA in Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chayim 670:2, when he notes that the coincidence of the festival with the anniversary of the dedication of the Altar suggests that celebrations involving food are appropriate, and certainly were appropriate songs and praises to take place at these festive meals, they qualify as Seudot Mitzva (meals constituting religious fulfillments.)] The recitation of the Hallel prayer, the omission of Tachanun, the absence of eulogies, and the thanksgiving additions to the Silent Devotion as well as the Grace after Meals, all contribute to setting a tone of rejoicing, aside from the commemoration of the miracles associated with finding a pure cruse of oil following the Hasmonean victory.

Our commitment to annually recalling the spiritual and military victories over the Syrian Greeks, which is the basis for our candle lighting and celebrating, is discussed by Rav Avraham Yitzchak HaKohen Kook, ZaTzaL, in his Talmudic commentary Ein Ayah. Rav Kook notes that while there have been many periods of persecution and deliverance during the course of Jewish history, the threats that the Hellenistic era posed to Jewish belief and national existence had the potential to alter fundamentally and forever our lifestyle and identity. It is for this reason that we commemorate Chanuka more than other events in Jewish history, which, while similarly traumatic, posed threats that were of relatively short duration. The author then presents an evocative interpretation of what the cruse of oil may have represented then, and continues to connote to this very day. Oto Pach HaShemen HaChatum, SheBeMeurah HaNeis, SheHu Romeiz Gam Kein Al HaShoresh HaYoteir Penimi SheBeEmuna, HaChazak VeEmotz BeOmek Nafshoteihem Shel Yisroel, SheMayim Rabot Lo Yuchlu LeChabot Et HaAhava, VeHu Atid LeShloach Oro Al Kol HaKochot HaMitpashtim LeHachayotom, LeHachayot Et HaMaasim BePoal VeEt HaDeot HaToriot HaMityachasim Lahem (That sealed cruse of oil, involved in the miracle also symbolizes the inner source of belief, strong and mighty, residing deep within the souls of the Jewish people, [a belief that] even mighty floods would never succeed in extinguishing [its love], and which in the future will send forth its light upon all of the powers that serve to give the Jewish people life, to enliven both the actions as well as the Tora ideals that are associated with this people.) [vol. 3, (Masechet Shabbat Chapt. 1-2), R. Zvi Yehuda Kook Foundation, Jerusalem, 5754, p. 66.]

Whereas we usually think of the lights of the Chanukia as manifestations of the Divine Blessing bestowed in the distant past upon the generation of the Maccabees, Rav Kook understands the lights that we kindle to correspond with an inner flame that is at least potentially present in us all, even those who may be completely unaware of it. Pirsumei Nissa (the publicizing of the miracle) therefore is not designed to simply have a cognitive effect upon the onlooker reminding him of a historical event; the flames also have the potential to accelerate an inner light and fire that burns with differing degrees of intensity, and that is outwardly visible to different extents for each of us.

A number of Hilchot Chanuka can be understood to take on new significance in light of Rav Kook's concept. The ideal that Melacha (creative physical activity) not be performed by either men or women during the time that the candles are lit [Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chayim, 670:1; Mishna Berura #3], and the prohibition against deriving benefit from the Chanuka lights [Ibid., 673:1], may be designed to assure that the flames will have our full attention so that we may consider how we might become more incandescent in a religious sense. The recommendation that each individual light his/her own Chanukia as a fulfillment of the Mehadrin Min HaMehadrin (the most beautiful of the most beautiful) level of observance of this commandment [Ibid., 671:2, RaM"A], might be intended to urge each individual family member to look within him/herself in search of that sealed cruse of oil and reflect upon his/her level of religious observance, rather than doing this vicariously, as part of a family unit in which others may be perceived as primarily responsible for the group's religious observance and sensibility. And the insistence that once the time for lighting approaches, even Tora learning becomes prohibited within one half hour of the earliest time to light the Menora [Ibid., 672, Mishna Berura #10; Sha'ar HaTziyon #14], suggests that no matter what level a person, even one who sees him/herself as a Tora scholar, has managed to achieve, the fires of motivation and devotion can always be stoked a little hotter, and more time and effort can be dedicated to fulfilling HaShem's commandments. Hopefully the flames that we ignite on Chanuka will not be limited to the approximately half hour that the average candle or oil wick burns each of the eight nights of the holiday, but will also figuratively fan the flames of religious devotion and commitment within us all.

Chag Urim Sameach!